The production team for "The Beach" bulldozes some of the sand dunes on Maya Bay to transform the island into the Western ideal of "paradise". |
At the end of The Beach, the main character, Richard, says that after all the things he went through during his soul-searching journey, he survived, but with a lot of scars.
The same is probably true with Maya Bay, where the movie was shot.
While there have been reports the Forestry Department was satisfied with the production's rehabilitation effort and plans to return the five-million-baht ($138,800) bond to 20th Century Fox, one local activist insisted that allowing the movie production to alter the national park was a big mistake and that the beach itself still bears some permanent scars.
Booskasem Kwo, an artist and native of Krabi, led the protest against The Beach's production.
"Since the production team moved out last November," he said, "the sand dunes have eroded by two or three metres. With no plants to collect and retain moisture, the sand has become very dry."
"The western wind, which blows directly into Maya Bay, has aggravated the erosion," Mr Booskasem continued. "With no sand dunes which act like a wall to protect the beach, I don't know how deep the erosion will be in the future," he said.
He travels to Maya Bay almost every month now to monitor its conditions.
To enable filming of the sea and to make the beach wide enough so that the characters could play football on it, The Beach’s production team bulldozed two dunes in front of Maya Bay. They also removed plants and weeds that grew on the beach and planted 60 coconut trees.
The production team filmed its final shot on Maya Bay in February, 1999. They were obliged under a contract made with the Forestry Department to return the beach to its original condition. The contract ended last October.
"The restoration team has removed the coconut trees from the island as promised. They also tried to recreate the sand dunes by dumping some sand in and tightening it with a back-hoe. They drove some bamboo poles into the sand, hoping that they would keep the sand in place while waiting for new plants to take root," Mr Booskasem said.
The poles did not hold. In early November last year, a severe storm swept into Maya Bay and took with it all the recreated sand dunes and most of the newly-grown plants. "The beach has weathered stronger storms. It has never eroded this much. I wish the Forestry Department and the Tourism Authority of Thailand could see what we have lost. Maya Bay is no longer the same.
"People from Twentieth Century Fox always claim that they rid the beach of rubbish. Why haven't they looked at the damage caused by their bulldozing of the sand dunes? Why haven't they shown responsibility?"
But Dr Chaweewan Hutacharern, director of Forest Environment Research and Development Division at the Forestry Department said, "The restoration contract expired on October 20. I inspected the work they have done. I think they did a great job. The team removed the coconut trees a few days after they finished the shooting. They dug up about 100 metres of the sand dunes out of a total length of 300 metres.
"About the erosion, it is probably caused by the unusually heavy storm this year. Every island suffered the same kind of erosion. Spider lilies were re-grown. They might appear a little dry now because it is the dry season. They will thrive again when rain falls. We asked that Beach Productions Ltd, which is doing the restoration work, retain water sprinklers even if the contract had expired. And they agreed to do it even if they had to pay about 40,000 baht a day for water."
Dr Chaweewan said staff from Beach Production are still stationed on the island to supervise the restoration.
She said 20th Century Fox has asked that since they had fulfilled their obligation under the contract, the five-million-baht bond they deposited against ecological damage be returned.
"We will have to wait for the Director General to approve the bond return. But as far as the inspection is concerned, I think everything looks fine. I am satisfied with the work." |